Making the Buried Element Easier

Yeti working a buried hide

On a regular basis (seems like every few months) the topic of the buried element comes up on the Friends of AKC Scentwork Facebook page. It goes something like this (every time): AKC should get rid of this element, women our age cannot set up heavy bins of water and sand for either trial OR practice, AKC should just have a vehicles element like everyone else, buried is just another container search, my dogs struggle with it, it takes forever to pass the classes, and on and on.

I have to admit that: 1. all of these things are true, and 2. I used to feel the same way. When I started trialing in AKC, Astra and I struggled with the buried element. We managed to pass Novice and, with some trouble, Advanced. But we got stuck in Excellent–failing at several trials. Finally, tired of wasting entry fees, I put my big girl panties on and decided to do some serious work. I set up bins of sand and water every day and we practiced, practiced, practiced. Until Astra learned to recognize the odor in sand and water, AND trace it to the correct bin. It is not just another container search, I learned by watching her, there are lots of subtleties involved in the way the odor is both very available AND inaccessible.

By the time we got to Master’s level, though, my shoulders were giving out under the strain of setting up 16 bins (for each session, I had to drag the bins out into my carport, because my yard was not big enough to practice in, And then I had to drag them back). And then, when talking to a trainer friend of mine, she suggested that I try training with small amounts of sand and water.

And this, my friends, I am here to tell you,  is the secret to this element.  

I have been teaching classes and practicing this way for the last several years and it works very well. Amazingly, the skills that the dogs learn on the small containers generally transfer seamlessly to the big containers during trials. I used to set up big bins once or twice just before a trial, just to make sure that there weren’t problems with the dog working them, but now I don’t bother.

Here is how I do it:

I use quart yogurt containers for the sand and water (I eat a lot of yoghurt) but you could use any small sized containers. I have students who use the small cheap Tupperware containers.  The yogurt containers gives me about 4 inches of depth (as the regulations require), but I you can do it with less depth perfectly well.

I put the q-tip directly in the bottom of container with the sand/water. The regulations for competition require that the q tips be in aquarium tubing stuck to the bottom of the container for water, and in tea strainers for sand, but I have found that you can leave these out in practice and it doesn’t make any difference to the dogs. The q tip will sink to the bottom of the water container after a minute or two anyway.

 Of course, you need to make sure you mark the containers as hot, as they will now be contaminated with oil residue.

I put the yogurt containers in the regulation sized bins. This helps prevent dogs from knocking the containers over, and provides the dog with a similar visual picture to the one that she will see at the trial—this will eventually help her target the containers, although at first she may wander around, following the scent plume.

Small container with sand in larger bin. This container is hot, so it is marked with blue tape, so that it can be easily identified.

I also start with the containers further apart than the regulation three feet. Fringing is the biggest problem in this element, and the further away your containers are from each other, the easier it will be for the dog to identify the correct container. After a few practice sessions, I will start moving the bins closer to each other until they are three feet apart, the way they will be in trial.

Water hide in small container

Bins about four feet apart for starting

In addition, I initially leave the cooling racks off of the containers, because I think it helps the dogs if they can get their noses down close to the sand or water, it makes the source a tiny bit  more accessible, and helps them figure out the puzzle. After the dog is alerting on the correct container the majority of the time, I will add the cooling racks to the top.

Of course, there are always dogs who will knock over the container, in spite of precautions. I usually put a tarp down on the floor when practicing inside, it makes clean-up much easier.

I doubt AKC is going to get rid of this element anytime soon, they have put a lot of thought into designing it, and now clubs have invested time and money in getting the equipment to use in trials. So I would encourage people to experiment with practicing with small containers, it is well worth the effort.

Want to get these posts delivered to your email? Click on the Home button on the left, scroll down to the bottom and put your email in the SUBSCRIBE box.

17 responses to “Making the Buried Element Easier”

  1. Liz Avatar
    Liz

    Great advice! Thank you.

    Like

    1. otchmx Avatar
      otchmx

      Boy do I have a lot to say about thisBut you are totally On point

      Like

  2. Shawn Albright Avatar
    Shawn Albright

    Love this article!

    Liked by 1 person

    1. Christine Noto Avatar

      Thanks so much for this informative article

      Like

  3. Kathy Feldmann Avatar
    Kathy Feldmann

    I couldn’t have written any better myself. I literally do the same exact thing. I think it teaches the dog to source better. And by putting the yogurt containers in the sterilite container with the wire rack on helps to give the dog an ” ah ha’ moment when they get in the ring. They know what they are there to do. Thank you for posting.

    Liked by 1 person

  4. Lisa Phillips Avatar
    Lisa Phillips

    Holy smokes! Great advice and will set this up for practice ASAP! Clooney’s worst element is clearly buried, we got through Novice reasonably fast, Advanced a little slower, but Excellent, well, I am not sure just how many times we’ve tried and we only have one single lonely Q to our name. Looking forward to seeing if this helps, I thinks it’s great on many levels.

    Liked by 1 person

  5. Pat Roddy Avatar
    Pat Roddy

    I finally tried this and I do like it not only from the standpoint of easier setup and teardown but I think it encourages my dogs to check in the middle of the large container rather than just around the edges. I believe checking just the edges has caused false alerts due to fringing. Whether this is true or not time will tell.

    Like

  6. Theresa Bosemer Avatar
    Theresa Bosemer

    Thanks, I will try this

    Like

  7. Christine Noto Avatar

    Thank you for this informative article

    Like

  8. Jennifer Hoover Avatar
    Jennifer Hoover

    I have just started to do buried in sand. But what you have written makes it a lot easier. Thanks.

    Like

  9. Heather Frost Avatar
    Heather Frost

    Great article

    Like

  10. Sue Royston Avatar
    Sue Royston

    Wonderful article! I’m wondering what kind of sand you use? Play sand? or the kind you get at the Sand & Gravel place? Thank you!

    Like

    1. ellenheavner Avatar

      Play sand is required by AKC.

      Like

  11. What You Don’t Understand About the Buried Element– Part Three – Sniffing Around Scent Work Avatar

    […] (Note: if you missed my other posts on the buried element, you can find them here: What You Don’t Understand about the Buried Element  and What You Don’t Understand About the Buried Element Part Two. Also Making the Buried Element Easier) […]

    Like

  12. Lisa S Avatar
    Lisa S

    I am wondering……. does the container within the container method pictured here keep the odor cascade a little more contained within the larger container rather than spreading as readily to nearby boxes?

    Like

    1. ellenheavner Avatar

      It still spreads plenty, according to my dogs. Thanks for the comment!

      Like

Leave a comment

I’m Ellen

A Scent Work trainer, instructor, competitor, student, and judge. Welcome to Sniffing Around Scent Work, a blog where I write about my experiences, thoughts and musings on my favorite past time.